Painful Pumping: Common Pain Points and How to Fix Them

Pumping your breast milk can be a great way to feed your baby, but let’s be honest, it may not always be comfortable. If you’ve ever thought, “Why does this hurt?” or “Am I doing something wrong?” you’re not alone. Most pumping struggles are incredibly common, and the good news is that many of them have simple fixes.

Here are the most common pumping pain points parents experience, plus practical, realistic ways to make pumping easier on your body and your sanity.

Nipple Pain or Soreness While Pumping

One of the biggest complaints with pumping is sore, tender, or downright painful nipples. This can happen for a few reasons, but the most common culprit is flange size.

How to fix it:

• Measure your nipples (not your areola) and make sure your flange fits correctly. Many people need a smaller size than what comes standard with pumps.
• Use a small amount of pumping lubricant (like coconut oil or pump spray) to reduce friction.
• notequal more milk — comfort is key.

If pain continues even with a good fit, consider checking for nipple damage or talking to a lactation consultant.

Clogged Ducts and Localized Breast Pain

Clogs can feel like hard, sore lumps and may cause localized pain or tenderness. Left untreated, they can lead to mastitis.

How to fix it:

• Pump or nurse frequently to keep milk moving.
• Use gentle breast massage before and duringpumping, focusing around the clogged area.
• Apply warmth before pumping and cold afterward to reduce inflammation.
• Avoid overly tight bras or pressure on your breasts.

If clogs are recurring, double-check your flange size and pumping schedule.

Painful Suction, Pinching, or Rubbing Sensation

If pumping feels like pinching, pulling, or rubbing instead of a rhythmic tug, something isn’t quite right.

How to fix it:

• Re-center your nipple in the flange tunnel before starting.
• Reduce suction settings and gradually increase only if comfortable.
• Replace pump parts regularly — worn valves or membranes can change suction and cause discomfort.

Pumping should feel strange, not painful. Trust your body if something feels off.

After Code

£159.99

£127.99

Momcozy Mobile Flow™ Hands-Free Breast Pump | M9

From £159.99 GBP

High Efficiency Multiple Modes APP Control Long Battery

Mobile Flow™ | M9 Wearable Breast Pump Replacement Parts

From £6.99 GBP

Swelling or Elastic Nipples During Pumping

Some people experience nipples swelling or stretching far into the flange tunnel (often called elastic nipples). This can cause discomfort and inefficient milk removal.

How to fix it:

• Use a smaller flange size or silicone inserts designed for elastic nipples.
• Avoid high suction levels that pull too much tissue into the tunnel.
• Take short breaks during pumping if swelling occurs.

Comfort-focused adjustments can make a huge difference here.

Low or Inconsistent Milk Output When Pumping

Few things are more frustrating than sitting attached to a pump and barely seeing drops. This can feel discouraging, especially if you’re used to baby transferring milk more efficiently.

How to fix it:

• Start with the stimulation/letdown mode(depending on your pump) for at least 2-3 minutes, then switch to expression once milk is flowing.
• Try hands-on pumping: gently massaging or compressing your breasts while pumping can increase output.
• Make sure you’re pumping often enough. Skipping sessions can quickly impact supply.

Also, remember: pumps are not as effective as babies. Output isn’t always a perfect reflection of your supply.

Leaking, Poor Seal, or Uneven Suction

If milk leaks during pumping or suction feels uneven, it can cause irritation and wasted milk.

How to fix it:

• Make sure flanges are properly positioned and fully sealed.
• Sit upright with good posture rather than leaning forward.
• Check that all pump parts are assembled correctly and fully dry.

A good seal protects your skin and improves efficiency.

After Code

£89.99

£71.99

All-in-one M5 Wearable Breast Pump - Painlessly Pump

From £89.99 GBP

More Comfort High Efficiency Portable More Discreet

M5 Breast Pump Replacement Parts

From £5.99 GBP

Time Stress and Mental Burnout from Pumping

While not physical pain, the mental load of pumping is very real. Watching the clock, stressing over ounces, and constantly cleaning parts can be exhausting.

How to fix it:

• Create a realistic pumping schedule that fits your
• Set up a dedicated pumping station with everything you need.
• Give yourself permission to multitask — read, scroll, watch a show, or relax.
• Remember that feeding your baby is not all-or-nothing. Any amount of milk you provide matters.

Reducing stress can actually help improve letdown and output.

Choosing to Have a Comfortable Pumping Experience

Pumping doesn’t have to hurt to be effective. Most pain points are signs that something needs adjusting — not that you’re failing or doing it wrong. Small tweaks like better flange sizing, lower suction, or hands-on pumping can make a world of difference.

Above all, listen to your body. Comfort supports consistency, and consistency supports your goals — whatever those goals may be. Pumping is a tool, not a test, and you deserve support every step of the way.

FAQs

Q1: Why does pumping sometimes hurt?

Pain while pumping is very common. It can result from incorrect flange size, high suction, nipple friction, or clogged ducts. Ensuring proper fit, adjusting suction, and using gentle massage can help.

Q2: How can I reduce nipple soreness during pumping?

• Use the correct flange size (measure your nipples, not your areola).
• Apply a small amount of pumping lubricant like coconut oil or pump spray.
• Ensure proper latch into the flange tunnel.
• If soreness persists, consult a lactation consultant.

Q3: What should I do if I have clogged ducts or localized breast pain?

• Pump or nurse frequently to keep milk moving.
• Gently massage the area before and during pumping.
• Apply warmth before pumping and cold afterward to reduce inflammation.
• Avoid tight bras or pressure on the breasts.

Q4: My milk output is inconsistent. How can I improve it?

• Start with the stimulation/letdown mode for 2–3 minutes, then switch to expression mode.
• Try hands-on pumping: gently massage or compress the breasts while pumping.
• Pump frequently and consistently.

Q5: What can I do if my nipples swell or feel pinched during pumping?

• Use a smaller flange size or silicone inserts for elastic nipples.
• Avoid high suction levels.
• Take short breaks during pumping if needed.

Q6: How can I reduce mental stress and burnout from pumping?

• Set a realistic pumping schedule.
• Create a dedicated pumping station with all needed supplies.
• Multitask while pumping—read, watch a show, or relax.
• Remember that any amount of milk you provide is valuable.